[RedCircle player will be added once episode UUID is available from Ken]

Getting passed over for a promotion is one of the most disorienting career moments you can experience, especially when you were certain you were the obvious choice. If you are sitting with that question right now, wondering what to do next, this episode is for you.

Most people respond to not getting promoted in one of two ways: they stew in the hurt, or they immediately start updating their resume. Both responses are completely understandable. Neither one actually moves your career forward.

In this episode, I walk you through a step-by-step approach for recovering from a promotion setback and using it as a genuine growth opportunity. I start with the emotional side, because you do get to be disappointed, and I give you a framework for processing that disappointment without letting it take over. Then I get tactical. I share five specific things to listen for when you seek feedback from the hiring manager, your HR business partner, or your own manager: a visibility gap, a skills gap, an advocacy gap, a timing issue, or what I call the invisible ceiling.

I also break down the "should I stay or should I go" question with explicit criteria for both paths. If you stay, I walk you through how to get promotion criteria in writing, set a realistic timeline, and find a sponsor (not just a mentor) who will say your name in rooms when you are not there. If you go, I share how to leave clean, take your diagnostic data with you, and make the move strategic rather than emotional.

Listen and catch the full episode here or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can also watch it and replay it on my YouTube channel, JanelAndersonPhD.

LINKS RELATED TO THIS EPISODE:

Episode 259 - What to Cover in Your One-on-One Meetings

I got passed over for a promotion. What do I do now? After a keynote a while back, someone came up to me with that exact question. And I could tell from their tone of voice and from their nonverbals, they were still processing it. It was still raw. So I asked them, how long ago was this? Was it recent? And they said it was about six weeks ago. And I realized they had some personal healing to do. It's a question I hear more than you might think, though. When somebody gets passed over for a promotion, most people either stew in the hurt or they clean up their resume and they're ready to move on and leave their organization. And both of those responses are completely understandable, but neither one of those responses actually helps. So let's talk about what actually does help and what to do when you don't get promoted.

Now, you get to be disappointed. Absolutely, you get to be disappointed. Disappointment means that you cared and that you tried and that you gave it your all. And that is absolutely not a weakness. That's an investment. It's an investment you were making in yourself. And it's an investment that you were hoping to make in the organization by moving into a different place on the org chart where you could lead differently. But there's a difference between processing something and stewing in your own juices. And only one of them is actually going to move your career forward. So I want you to decide consciously how much time you're going to give yourself to be upset. For this person who was talking to me after the keynote, being that raw about not getting the promotion six weeks later, I'm going to say it was just a little bit indulgent for them to still be stewing in their frustration and anger over not getting promoted. So you need to decide consciously how much time you're going to give yourself to be upset. A day? A weekend? Most of us are going to need a week or so to really, really process the emotion of it. But not two weeks or six weeks. Find the place where you can truly do the emotional processing of your disappointment without getting indulgent about how long you're going to stew. Once you've decided, put a note in your calendar so that you hold yourself accountable. And then actually do the processing. Whether you're talking to a close friend about it, journaling, writing it down, speaking into a voice notes app, working with a therapist or a business coach, whatever it takes for you to actually do the processing. Do that processing so that when you come out the other side of it, you're not holding on to residual anger and frustration towards your organization or towards the person who didn't select you for the promotion.

Now we're going to get really tactical about this. If you truly want to learn from and recover from not getting the promotion, and position yourself to get the promotion the next time, then you need to look under the hood and do some diagnostic work to figure out why you didn't get the promotion. Because just saying, that manager didn't even explain why I didn't get promoted, or I'm angry about not getting promoted, is not helpful. We need to have you look under the hood and find out exactly what happened. And this is quite frankly the part that most people skip, and it's the most important part. You need to find out why. Part of that's going to come from introspection, but part of that is going to come from frank feedback from other people. Now this isn't going to be comfortable, but it's the only way to get useful data.

The most important question here is: who is going to give you a straight answer? Not everyone in your organization will. The most obvious choices are the hiring manager, your HR business partner who was probably involved in the process, and your own manager. Think about which one of those people is going to give you the best and most honest feedback. Ideally you could get feedback from all three and triangulate. When you ask them, let them know that your feelings will not be hurt by their frank feedback. And then you have to take personal responsibility for yourself to not let your feelings get hurt. It might sting in the moment, but you're going to take it as information outside your field of awareness and learn from it. I highly recommend taking lots of notes during conversations like this. You could also ask, is it okay if I use an AI recording tool so that I have the transcript to go back and look at? That can be really helpful because it frees you up to be fully present in the moment.

In this part of the conversation, I want you to be listening for five different things. The first thing to look for is a visibility gap. Does the decision maker above your manager actually know your work and your reputation, or do you only exist on your manager's radar? How well known are you in the organization? This really speaks to your personal brand. If you're not a known entity and somebody else who maybe doesn't have as much technical skill as you gets the job because they're more well known, that's very important feedback for you. Getting more visibility in the organization is absolutely something you can do. It's a solvable problem.

The second thing to listen for is a skills gap. Was there a specific competency they were looking for that you didn't have? This could be technical skills, or it could be a leadership competency, especially if you're looking for a move into a leadership role. This is good news because once you know what it is, you can go after those skills. Maybe you need to look outside your organization to develop them. Volunteering in civic organizations, your community, your school, are all ways to shore up that competency gap.

The third thing I want you to be listening for is an advocacy gap. Did you clearly and explicitly let the right people know that you really wanted this promotion? Assuming that your manager knows is not the same as advocating for yourself and letting your manager know, I really want this and I think I would be able to do a great job at this. A lot of times we implicitly think that other people know how much we want something, but they might think you were just seeing what happened. If you really wanted that promotion, you need to let people know you want it and that you're ready for it.

The fourth thing to listen for is timing. Are you really ready for it? Are you genuinely well positioned for this promotion, or are you what I like to call promotion adjacent? You're close, but you're not quite there yet. Sometimes the honest answer you're going to hear from somebody is not yet. And a great follow-up question is: what will it take for me to be ready? What does readiness look like? Then you can start to work towards filling in that gap so that the next time a promotion comes around, you have what it takes.

The fifth thing I want you to be listening for is what I call the invisible ceiling. Are you so good at your current job that leadership can't possibly picture you leaving that role to do something else? A good question to ask is: if I had gotten that promotion, what do you think my backfill would look like? If you start hearing people saying things like, we can't imagine what it would be like to have you leave that role, you're irreplaceable, that is feedback telling you that you might need to do some lateral development with your coworkers so that you're not such a unicorn that they can't imagine your unit functioning without you. All of these things are good things to know. To recap, the five things to listen for: visibility, skills gap, advocacy gap, timing, and the invisible ceiling.

Now the next logical question people ask me is: should I stay or should I go? Once you have that diagnosis from those first five things, now it's time to ask yourself that question. I want you to get explicit about the criteria you're going to use to decide. A lot of people just jump the gun and say, I'm out of here, because their feelings are hurt. But if you found out something specific about what was missing, taking a lateral move to a different organization where you have to prove yourself all over again might be more of a setback than a bump forward.

If you stay, you want to get explicit criteria from your manager on what promotion-ready you looks like specifically. Ideally get it in writing. You might take notes during that conversation and then send those notes back in an email and say, just to recap our discussion, you said these things were the missing link for me. Do I have this right? Second, set a timeline. Give yourself 12 to 18 months. In that timeframe, you have work to do. You're working on whatever gaps you found, and then it's a bit of a waiting game for a promotional opportunity to come available. Third, find a sponsor. A mentor is the person you can ask dumb questions to. A sponsor is different. A sponsor is a person who is going to advocate for you. A sponsor is someone who will say your name in rooms when you're not there. They're going to be promoting you in ways that you can't necessarily promote yourself.

If you choose to leave, I want it to be intentional and strategic. This should not be an emotional decision. The worst time to search for a job is when you're angry. Take the diagnostic data with you so that you don't land in the same situation at the next place. And leave clean. Leave with your bridges intact. You're not burning bridges on the way out. That is not helpful for anyone.

So if you are that person who has recently been passed over for a promotion, or maybe you realize it wasn't that recent and you're really hanging onto it, here is your call to action this week. Have at least one honest conversation with somebody who will tell you the truth. Go in with zero defensiveness and one question: what would promotion-ready me look like? And then what you do with the answer is up to you. Being passed over is not the end of the story. Have being passed over for a promotion simply be a data point. And the question is whether you are going to put that data into play to make your next career move just a little bit closer. All right, my friends, have a great week and I'll be back here on the Working Conversations Podcast next week, answering more of your questions. Take care.